what role does daisy play in gatsby's downfall

Your brain hurts. She stays majority of the week, which leads to Gatsby having to fire his workers to prevent rumors from forming. Both Tom and Wilson realize that their wives are having affairs; however, only Tom knows who Daisy's affair is with. Gatsby requests if Nick can reintroduce him with Daisy. I wonder how strong a feeling can actually get before it is too much to bear. Happy May to the Odyssey community! Imagine hearing about a friend or family members death and not truthfully knowing how they died. Book Guides. Days later, Jordan tells Nick Gatsby wishes for him to invited himself and Daisy over so they could meet for an afternoon. Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. (7.229-233). At times I tried to keep up with the trends but most of the time I found that I was always late to them. I don't think he had ever really believed in its existence before. Our citation format in this guide is (chapter.paragraph). After a talk with Nick, he returns to Daisy and the converse and head to his house next door. You'll also receive an email with the link. Songs About Being 17Grey's Anatomy QuotesVine Quotes4 Leaf CloverSelf Respect, 1. Chapter 3: Gatsby's smile He had one of those rare smiles with a quality of eternal reassurance in it, that you may come across four or five times in life. There are many ways to compare them, but in this chapter in particular what seems important is whether each woman is able to maintain coherence and integrity. Gatsbys fantasy of Daisy undergoes a slow demise when he meets her daughter, and when he learns that she is simply unwilling to renounce her entire history with Tom for Gatsbys sake. Best Summary and Analysis: The Great Gatsby, Chapter 7, Get Free Guides to Boost Your SAT/ACT Score, Comparing and contrasting Daisy and Jordan, how undereducated and dumb Tom actually is, the first time we saw them at the end of Chapter 1. Studying for seven hours straight, slightly brain dead and disoriented. She wants Gatsby to be the solution to her worries about each successive future day, rather than an imprecation about the choices she has made to get to this point. Gatsby welcomed everyone to his soires to enjoy his hospitality; that is how we met and we became close ever since. Daisy assumes that he is only pretending, and that he is actually talking to Myrtle. And I realize thats all I have left. Tom asks a policeman for details of the accident. But Ive found that these are the clothes that I feel most confident and like myself in. Gatsby seems to have no feelings at all about the dead woman, and instead only worries about what Daisy and how she will react. After the accident, even though Gatsby takes responsibility for Myrtles death, Daisy once again chooses Tom over Gatsby. This case of mistaken identity contributes to her death, as she assumes that Tom would be driving the same car back from the city that he took there. She asks Tom to take her home. They're leaving and you're the last one of the group left at school. "I know I'm not very popular. He forces a trip to Manhattan, demands that Gatsby explain himself, systematically dismantles the careful image and mythology that Gatsby has created, and finally makes Gatsby drive Daisy home to demonstrate how little he has to fear from them being alone together. The free trial period is the first 7 days of your subscription. During my time abroad, we were encouraged not to wear athletic clothing to fit in with the European culture. Shouldnt those around us love us for us rather than the clothes we are wearing? It turns out that Gatsby's money comes from illegal sales of alcohol in drugstores, just as Tom had predicted when he first met him. WebDaisy doesn't necessarily want to break up the life they've built. You will also often be asked to compare Tom and Wilson, two characters who share some plot details in common.This passage, which explicitly contrasts these two men's reactions to finding out their wives are having affairs, is a great place to start. This is Nick telling us what Michaelis described overhearing, so Myrtles words have gone through a double male filter. The child, relinquished by the nurse, rushed across the room and rooted shyly into her mother's dress. Wealthy, powerful characters such as Tom Buchanan are the major causes of violence introduced because they are selfish and careless. WebDaisy Buchanan Is Responsible For Gatsby's Death. In addition It is interesting that the vast majority of the crime or near crime that is described is theftthe taking of someone elses property. In many people's eyes, Gatsby has it all as he is wealthy and has a large mansion. Tom initially picks her up by pressing his body inappropriately into hers on the train station platform. Once again we see the powerful attraction of Daisy's voice. The 5 Strategies You Must Be Using to Improve 4+ ACT Points, How to Get a Perfect 36 ACT, by a Perfect Scorer. For much of the novel Tom exists only as an idea in Gatsbys mind. How does Nick Carraway first meet Jay Gatsby? With many college semesters coming to a close, students find themselves procrastinating. To Gatsby, the . Not only will you gain valuable writing experience, but youll get to choose your own topics and write one response a week to one of our top trending articles. "The Bles-sed pre-cious! All that Gatsby wants is Daisy, but Daisy repeatedly prevents him from attaining this goal of possessing her completely. Mr. Gatsby received a medal in the Great War, which says, Major Jay Gatsby, For Valour Extraordinary. He told people and myself he was an Oxford man who came back to the United States to pursue an entrepreneurial business. (7.316-317). Once in a while she looked up at him and nodded in agreement. Their relationship, now very, Gatsbys greatness is not in the vastness of his wealth. 409 Words | 2 Pages. Nick notes that the way Daisy speaks to Gatsby is enough to reveal their relationship to Tom. Her eyes fell on Jordan and me with a sort of appeal, as though she realized at last what she was doingand as though she had never, all along, intended doing anything at all. Twice as long as every other chapter, it first ratchets up the tension of the Gatsby-Daisy-Tom triangle to a breaking point in a claustrophobic scene at the Plaza Hotel, and then ends with the grizzly gut punch of Myrtles death. A Comprehensive Guide. Compare their readiness to forgive each other anythingeven murder!with Gatsbys insistence that its his way or no way. Gatsby demands that Daisy tell Tom that she has never loved him. There is nothing left to die. (7.409-410). Then Myrtle ran out into the street toward a car coming from New York. Your favorite beach reads and binge-worthy Netflix shows. He was in love with the Daisy Buchannan he knew in Louisville. hbspt.cta.load(360031, '4efd5fbd-40d7-4b12-8674-6c4f312edd05', {}); Have any questions about this article or other topics? Gatsby makes it sound like she had to choose between getting into a head-on collision with another car coming the other way on the road or hitting Myrtle, and at the last second chose to hit Myrtle. She dances, but she does not hear the same song as me. At the party, Nick finally meets his host, who he learns is in love with Daisy and has always been. Get the latest articles and test prep tips! (7.241). Neither, Nick and his friend Jordan Baker attend and sit at table with a man and a young woman. In reality, Gatsby is miserable. Looking for a way to spend your summer doing something creative and fulfilling? See how other students and parents are navigating high school, college, and the college admissions process. WebDaisy gets married to Tom Buchanan because she can no longer wait for Gatsby. When he says Daisy wouldnt leave him for a common swindler whod have to steal the ring he put on her finger, he implies that hed understand Daisy leaving him for another wealthy man, but cant accept her betraying him with someone of lower status. Were excited to hear from you! From the way Daisy looks at and talks to Gatsby, Tom suddenly figures out that she and Gatsby are having an affair. Our response writers have been keeping us supplied with engaging content to get us through these last few weeks of the semester. This very famous quotation is a great place to start. There is a short, but crucial, argument about who will take which car. But this is also the chapter where dreams come to die. Move on to the summary of Chapter 8, or revisit the summary of Chapter 6. That was it. As I was reflecting on his death I thought, Gatsby turned out all right at the end; it [was] what preyed on Gatsby, what foul dust floated in the wake of his dreams that temporarily closed out my interest in the abortive sorrows and short winded elations of men (2)., To start with, she thinks Gatsby is wealthy and falls in love with him. "Throw me down and beat me, you dirty little coward!" Why does Myrtle run out in front of Gatsbys car? Everyone is restless and nervous. WebGatsbys obsessive behavior and lack of sensitivity, combined with Toms decisions and desire for revenge against Gatsby for taking In society peoples egos appear to come before the ones they love. Sometimes it can end up there. Oqa]9}paVcpV|yxqXL#K}f\h(|\u^nsfB7mo>P4_,.T.YKJ~VoF56 7ahl;x4boF~0p]UvkA1Xr! Let's go back, Tom, tomorrow!" Daisy is not capable of measuring up to Gatsbys expectations., Daisy are getting ready to meet for the first time in 5 years. I think back to the day I met him; the day I started loving someone more than I have ever loved myself. But after ordering and returning items multiple times due to feeling uncomfortable in them, I realized that this wasnt my style. Daisy was superficial. He once told me that he was from the Middle West and his family was deceased. When Michaelis left, he heard Myrtle and Wilson fighting. WebNick characterizes her as a careless person who smashes things up and then retreats behind her money. Nick is also Daisys cousin, which enables him to observe and assist the resurgent love affair between Daisy and Gatsby. The College Entrance Examination BoardTM does not endorse, nor is it affiliated in any way with the owner or any content of this site. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% At the same time, this is the exact moment when Gatsby is delusional dreams start breaking down. Poor attempt at coping with finals, but hey, you can't think about that biology exam anymore, you're just numbing your pain. His neighbour is the wealthy and mysterious man named Jay Gatsby. In no way am I denying that Daisy never had feelings for Gatsby, but she most certainly left him high and dry in the end of story, letting him take responsibility for Myrtles death. If you don't see it, please check your spam folder. Daisy and Tom have an intimate moment together as they figure out what they are going to do next. This moment of truth has stripped Daisy and Tom down to the basics. But he is so unused to wielding it that his best effort is to lock Myrtle up and then to listen to her emasculating insults and provocations. Dt(&n sj.yBA03)050oc):f08*h h%>\!Lf\f{iv Even with Gatsby, her love outside of her window, begging to take her away, she stayed with Tom. WebA young man (he turns thirty during the course of the novel) from Minnesota, Nick travels to New York in 1922 to learn the bond business. This treatment of Myrtles body might be one place to go when you are asked to compare Daisy and Myrtle in class. SparkNotes PLUS In fact, the reader meets Tom long before Gatsby does, and understands that Tom will not back down from Daisy gracefully. Gatsby and Daisy admit that they've been having an affair, Gatsby demands that Daisy tell Tom that she has never loved him. The fall of the Great Gatsby was the result of Gatsby putting his trust in a false love. Here are the top three response articles of last week: People havent always been there for me but music always has. Taylor Swift. First, there is the pairing of Daisy and Jordan, whose outlooks on life are confirmed to be diametrically opposed. "Bles-sed pre-cious," she crooned, holding out her arms. The only purpose of the parties was to solicit Daisy's attention; now that they are reunited, the parties have lost their purpose. AB/n* (@l@SiSK{0'7&`p !]%Rpp ^lm\DP+y06hy7lU(nPl While Tom most clearly stands in the way of Gatsbys love for Daisy, Daisy herself functions as an antagonist as well. Similarly, any romantic ideas Daisy may have had about Gatsby vanish when she learns that he is a criminal. For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! Some of it was good and some of it was bad. The stark contrast here between the oddly ghostly nature of the car that hits Myrtle and the visceral, gruesome, explicit imagery of what happens to her body after it is hit is very striking. Tom Buchanan is the main antagonist in The Great Gatsby. I'd never understood before. Mutability of Identity. Did mother get powder on your old yellowy hair? It passed, and he began to talk excitedly to Daisy, denying everything, defending his name against accusations that had not been made. He throws extravagant parties in hopes her being there. Finally, here we can see how Pammy is being bred for her life as a future "beautiful little fool", as Daisy put it. There is no doubt Tom was a terrible husband, but he cannot be blamed for Daisy deciding to stay with him. To him, she was a goddess, and amazing woman he felt was above his standing. Like Tom, Daisy is deeply attached to her upper class lifestyle. The mighty fall of Jay Gatsby was the result of Daisy and her shallow self. This ultimately leads Gatsby to his untimely fate. $24.99 Here, she is pointing out Wilsons weak and timid nature by egging him on to treat her the way that Tom did when he punched her earlier in the novel. Her husband, Tom, denies it. Like Daisy, Tom only cares about himself. On the other hand, Jordan is a pragmatic and realistic person, who grabs opportunities and who sees possibilities and even repetitive cyclical moments of change. The Treatment of Women. Exploring different styles is important, but finding clothes that you feel most comfortable and confident in is even more significant. Webin this chapter the rain plays a big role in Gatsby's downfall how does the statement, "money can't buy happiness" apply to this book so far? As they drive off, Nick sees Myrtle in an upstairs window staring at Tom and Jordan, whom she assumes to be his wife. "She's got an indiscreet voice," I remarked. Does it make them more or less likely to act out to be there? Similarly, the normally weak and ineffectual Wilson overpowers his wife enough to lock her up when he finds out about the affair shes been having. Tom and Gatsby go outside, and Gatsby points out that it's his house is directly across the bay from theirs. The Great Gatsby: Chapter 5 Summary. Your group members can use the joining link below to redeem their group membership. "You think I'm pretty dumb, don't you?" One of the most iconic couples in literature is without a doubt James Gatsby and Daisy, but personally, I feel she is responsible for his death. Subscribe now. Gatsbys fantasy of Daisy undergoes a slow demise when he meets her daughter, and when he learns that she is simply unwilling to renounce her entire history with Tom for Gatsbys sake. When Gatsby first met her, she was a rich girl and he was just any other guy. No. Finally, it is interesting that Nick renders these reactions as health-related. It was too late. WebGatsby's obsession with Daisy is his fatal flaw and leads to his tragic death. Does Manhattan affect the way the characters behave? It is fitting that just as lots of wool is removed from lots of eyes, as Gatsby is source of wealth is revealed, and as Daisy is shown not to be the fairytale figment of Gatsbys imagination, the idea of faades, false impressions, and mistaken identity is front and center. Even though hopeful dreaming like Gatsbys seems to be oriented toward the future, Nick claims that such dreaming is stuck in the past. ", Gatsby and I in turn leaned down and took the small reluctant hand. These chains still hold me to someone who left a long time ago. In the novel, The Great Gatsby, Daisy Buchanan, a selfish and careless woman, is the person with whom Jay Gatsby, the protagonist, is infatuated. What are some of the overall themes in Gatsby? Nick leaves Gatsby alone. Gatsby is sightless to the fact that he is in danger due to his desire for Daisy. (7.254-266). I hear the last words of the song and I lift my head cautiously. Comparing and contrasting Daisy and Jordan) is one of the most common assignments that you will get when studying this novel. They uncover everything about him that I promised myself I would forget. to start your free trial of SparkNotes Plus. Throughout middle school and high school, I played cross country and soccer, leading me to stick with athleisure most days. She represents a form of symbolic capital and also represents a certain insincerity of the upper classes. Ask questions; get answers. Myrtle fights by provoking and taunting. No application required to sign up. Daisys lack of self reliance and ignorance prompt her to be easily led into making bad decisions, causing her to lash out and be held responsible for the death of Gatsby. WebForeshadowing. We've known this ever since the first time we saw them at the end of Chapter 1, when he realized that they were cemented together in their dysfunction. Morality and Ethics. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. He also makes a dirty joke about the Buchanans butler having to yell over the phone that he simply cannot send Toms body to Myrtle in this heat. This impression is further underscored by the fairy tale imagery that follows the connection of Daisy's voice to money. Tom, Nick, and Jordan drive home together in Tom's car. Daisy complains about Tom, and Tom serially cheats on Daisy, but at the end of the day, they are unwilling to forgo the privileges their life entitles them to. After all, Jimmy Gatz became someone he wasnt (in some ways illegal) in order to win her heart. Death and Failure. The way she exaggerates everything and bounces from one subject to the next exposes her phony attitude. Throughout the story, rumors and stories are shared about him. The 5 Strategies You Must Be Using to Improve 160+ SAT Points, How to Get a Perfect 1600, by a Perfect Scorer, Free Complete Official SAT Practice Tests. To him, she was a goddess, and amazing woman he felt was above his standing. Nick, Gatsby, Daisy, Jordan, and Tom have lunch together and decide to go to Manhattan for the day to escape the heat. Everyones desire for someone who is not their spouse is underscored by the way that an ongoing wedding is continuously described as deeply unappealing throughout the chapter. "I did love him oncebut I loved you too. . WebAn integral part of the plot, Daisy conveys the meaning of the novel, with her multi-dimensional personality and her relation to the conflicts. All she cared about is money. Let's take a look. Why does Gatsby arrange for Nick to have lunch with Jordan Baker? To him, her voice marks her as a prize to be collected. Maybe yelling at him is her only recourse in a life where she has no actual ability to control her life or bodily integrity. Daisys body is never even described, beyond a gentle indication that she prefers white dresses that are flouncy and loose. Need some creative inspiration? In this case it's not just Daisy herself, but also his dream of being with her inside his perfect memory. WebGatsby's obsession with Daisy is his fatal flaw and leads to his tragic death. WebAfter Daisy hits and kills Myrtle, Gatsby refuses to leave without her. If that happens, Gatsby will be there to protect her, and it also gives him a reason to fight with Tom. When Jay left for war, she lost her handsome, rich soldier, falling in love with the wealthy Tom Buchanan. Are they secretly the most romantic couple in the book? What SAT Target Score Should You Be Aiming For? WebNow it was again a green light on a dock. Purchasing Married life is suffocating, and these characters spend significant energies trying to break free. Tom starts revealing what he knows about Gatsby from his investigation. Daisy cannot do this, and Gatsby's dreams are dashed. But how can one achieve this with a child in the picture frame? . Daisy has a number of functions in the novel. Tom's relationships demonstrate his careless with feelings., Who really caused Jay Gatsbys downfall? Nick and Gatsby show up to have lunch with Daisy, Jordan, and Tom. But do we really need to dress to impress? Wilson was so sick that he looked guilty, unforgivably guiltyas if he had just got some poor girl with child. Tom calls Gatsby crazy and says that of course Daisy loves himand that he loves her too even if he does cheat on her all the time. ", Angry as I was, as we all were, I was tempted to laugh whenever he opened his mouth. Foreshadowing is a significant technique in The Great Gatsby. Without Tom's money, Daisy felt she would be nothing. All the money, the flashy car, and clothes, were all for her. Daisy and Gatsby are oth dreamers and one of the things they share is their idealized imaged of their relationship the first time around. Afterward he kept looking at the child with surprise. | He is unwilling to accept the idea that Daisy has had feelings for someone other than him, that she has had a history that does not involve him, and that she has not spent every single second of every day wondering when he would come back into her life. On the other hand, the womanizing Tom primly and hypocritically rants about the downfall of morality and the possibility that people of different races will be allowed to intermarry. (7.48-52). Your friends are all done with their finals and you still have one more to go. SparkNotes Plus subscription is $4.99/month or $24.99/year as selected above. This existential ennui goes a long way to helping explain why she seizes on Gatsby as an escape from routine. (7.160). What role does Daisy play in Gatsby's downfall? (one code per order). Gatsby and Daisy drive home together. Their memories make clear that his entire story about himself was a shama sham that worked, until it didnt, like the faades of the main characters in the story. Gatsby has all the money in the world but it can not buy him happiness toward Daisy How is the use if flashback effective in this chapter- think in regards to the telling of Gatsby's life? You didn't study enough and you're pretty sure that last final dropped your grade at least 10 percent. Nick is happy whenever he gets to demonstrate how undereducated and dumb Tom actually is. Consider Nick, Catherine, Meyer Wolfsheim, Klipspringer, Nick, Gatsby himself, Jordan, Tom. At first, Tom jokes about Wilson getting some business at last, but when he sees the situation is serious, he stops the car and runs over to Myrtle's body. It turns out that Gatsby has replaced all of his servants with ones sent over by Wolfshiem. The narration switches back to Nick's point of view, as Tom, Nick, and Jordan are driving back from Manhattan. "I suppose the latest thing is to sit back and let Mr. Nobody from Nowhere make love to your wife. We're using this system since there are many editions of Gatsby, so using page numbers would only work for students with our copy of the book. Nick never sees Tom as anything other than a villain; however, it is interesting that only Tom immediately sees Gatsby for the fraud that he turns out to be. she cried to Gatsby. h5!*eT\_cZP$[UBu7.#OeTaAK^!O fvVh_{^Jw]Zk[Uu$2X`. He feels threatened by the idea of the lower classes encroaching on his privileged life. In the novel, Jay Gatsby overcomes his poor past to gain an incredible amount of money and a limited amount of social cache in 1920s NYC, only to be rejected by the "old money" crowd. How is alcohol used in the novel? In the novel The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby's longing for Daisy Buchanan leads him to his own downfall. ,FB. Youve finished packing and found out you passed all of your classes! But realizing the fact that Gatsby cant give her a luxurious life, she chooses Tom as her husband without any doubt. The day is set and they meet. But she continues to sway from one direction to the next, while I cannot seem to remember how to move. It was full of moneythat was the inexhaustible charm that rose and fell in it, the jingle of it, the cymbals' song of it. WebThis essay will focus on the relationship between Daisy Buchanan and Jay Gatsby in the novel The Great Gatsby (1925). He can not get the vision of her out of his mind. Gatsby stops throwing parties at his house and instead carries on an affair with Daisy. The fall of the Great Gatsby was the result of Gatsby putting his trust in a false love. She weeps when he shows her his collection of sumptuous English shirts, and seems genuinely overjoyed at his success. It's clear that once again Gatsby has fundamentally misunderstood Tom and Daisy's relationship. Get Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more! I dont know how well we ended up fitting in, especially when we were speaking English most of the time, but nonetheless. In short, Gatsby He is an adulterer, abusive, and authoritative. She threw away Gatsby's love letter, promising her he would return, for Tom, whose wealth was certain and convenient. So crucial is this atmospheric element, that every movie adaptation of this novel makes sure that the actors are covered in sweat during these scenes, making it almost as uncomfortable to watch them as it is to imagine making it through that day. . Michaelis was shocked to hear this, because usually Wilson was a meek man. Has our narrator been spinning Gatsbys behavior from the get-go? She conforms to the social standard of American femininity in the 1920s in order to avoid such tension-filled issues as her undying love for Gatsby. Sure, these items could be considered trendy or timeless and not fit a specific style. He was willing to do anything for her. The nanny brings Tom and Daisy's daughter into the room and Gatsby is shocked to realize that the child actually exists and is real. Third, Daisy and Jordan remember a man named Biloxi who talked his way into Daisy and Toms wedding, and then talked his way into staying at Jordans house for three weeks as he recuperated from a fainting spell. Odyssey will continue to spotlight top response articles on our homepage every week, and in our brand new newsletter Overheard on Odyssey. Its been so long since I have felt big enough to take up and control my five foot seven figure. Renew your subscription to regain access to all of our exclusive, ad-free study tools. Just tell him the truththat you never loved himand it's all wiped out forever." His count of enchanted objects had diminished by one." Michaelis wasn't even sure of its colorhe told the first policeman that it was light green. . repeated Tom incredulously. WebDaisy is overwhelmed by his luxurious lifestyle, and when he shows her his extensive collection of English shirts, she begins to cry. I feel my stomach drop like Im on a rollercoaster that only seems to go down. In his mind, Daisy has been pining for him as much as he has been longing for her, and he has been able to explain her marriage to himself simply by eliding any notion that she might have her own hopes, dreams, ambitions, and motivations. Tom grabs Wilson and tells him that the yellow car that hit Myrtle is not Tom's, and that he was only driving it before giving it back to its owner. [B+Y*k3sFYxX3Nkowz~mH/Uew8h{ s">;|0nH}j&HnP2%rs&UA5L@]voum`o4F/m:jvT_)7h9h1+@RE')K"~ Ga^8xUMPDU7UuVUl7 @ vM@V.^.ZyyEwx8~QBz):Ti)q~mmqwk\4&Fzf9.( What is the importance of the character Owl Eyes? Nick is happy to do it, and they plan for a day after Gatsby has had a chance to get Nicks lawn cut. Years prior to the events of the novel, when Gatsby left to join the war effort, Daisy decided to give up on her love for Gatsby and run with a fast and rich crowd. Did Daisy leave Tom when she had the chance? For all Daisy's evident weaknesses, it is a testament to her psychological strength that she is simply unwilling to recreate herself, her memories, and her emotions in Gatsby's image. The plan is for Daisy and Gatsby to tell Tom about their relationship, and for Daisy to leave Tom. Road-tripping with your friends? A+ Student Essay: The Automobile as a Symbol in The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald and The Great Gatsby Background. His egotistic domineer could speak for itself. The appearance of Daisy's daughter and Daisys declaration that at some point in her life she loved Tom have both helped to crush Gatsby's obsession with his dream. WebEven though she loves him, Daisy plays a crucial role in Gatsbys downfall. Their honesty makes what they are doingconspiring to get away with murder, basicallycompletely transparent. We have no idea what Wilson has been saying to her to provoke this attack.

Move With Nicole Pilates Calendar, Articles W

what role does daisy play in gatsby's downfall